Skip to content

The bench

A leather shop on the main drag in Nashville, Indiana.

Reynolds Leather sits at 40 N Van Buren Street in downtown Nashville, in Brown County. Jackets, chaps, and vests are on the floor for try-on. Leather patches and keychains are American leather, made in the store. What ships: keychains, hats, gifts, patches, and shirts printed in-house.

The shop is under brothers Jimmy and Andrew Tilton. The floor still runs the way a rider shop should: size you by looking, pull the coat, and send you back onto Van Buren wearing it. That is why jackets are fitted in the shop.

Custom work is part of the counter. Custom tee designs are $10, drawn at the bench. Laser engraving, hat patches, and painted vests are quoted in the shop — they are not the $10 tee fee. Racing jackets are try-on in store, $199. Bring a drawing or we will sketch one. Same-day pickup is common if you can wait downtown or loop back after lunch.

Online checkout, when connected, is on this website through Square. You do not leave for a separate storefront. Until payments are turned on, walk in or call (812) 988-0147.

Reynolds Leather storefront at 40 N Van Buren Street, Open sign in the doorway

Van Buren Street

Number 40, stone and sage siding.

The shop porch faces the parade route. Come in for a fitting, or sit out front while we work a hide on the table.

Hours and map

Custom work

Patches from the bench. Jackets you try on here.

One-off patches and collabs, made in the shop. Racing jackets $199 — try on in store.

Trucker hat with a Bigfoot Center Nashville Indiana leather patch

Custom hat

Bigfoot Center

Local collab trucker — Nashville Indiana leather patch with Bigfoot in the hills.

Brown trucker hat with a Hoosier Worm Daddy leather patch

Custom hat

Hoosier Worm Daddy

Custom leather patch for a local worm farmer. Drawn and cut in the shop.

Custom Kiss the Cook racing jacket, Nashville Indiana — in-store only

Jacket

Kiss the Cook In-store · $199

Racing jacket for the local shop Kiss the Cook. Try on in person, $199. Fitted in the shop.

Custom HAWK leather jacket with eagle back graphic dated 5-5-08 — in-store only

Jacket

HAWK 5-5-08 In-store · $199

Back graphic on a leather jacket. Fitted in the shop, $199 — never boxed for mail.

Custom painted catfish art on a brown leather vest — in-store only

Vest

Catfish vest In-store / custom

Painted catfish on a leather vest. Custom art stays on the floor until you wear it out.

On the street

2026 Spring Blossom Parade

The shop porch sits on the parade route in downtown Nashville.

2026 Spring Blossom Parade seen from the Reynolds Leather porch — 2026 Spring Blossom Parade — from the shop porch.

2026 Spring Blossom Parade looking out from inside Reynolds Leather — 2026 Spring Blossom Parade — looking out from the shop.

What we will not do

No jacket in a box, sight unseen.

Jackets, racing jackets, and vests belong to the floor — jackets $199, try-on in store. v1 of this site sells the goods that do not need a fitting.

Stand in the doorway